Neurogenesis continues to occur throughout life in the dentate gyrus of the hippocampus and may be related to hippocampus-dependent learning. We have recently reported that there is an enhancement of neurogenesis in the hippocampus only when BrdU is administered 6days prior to starting spatial training but not when training started either 1day or 11days following BrdU administration. In that study, all rats were perfused on day 16 after BrdU injection in order to compare cells of the same age (i.e. 16day old cells) and thus the survival time after learning was different between groups. This study was designed to address whether the amount of time that passed following training could also contribute to the effects of spatial learning on hippocampal neurogenesis and whether there was differential new neuron activation in response to spatial learning that depended on the age of new cells at the time of spatial learning. Here we tested whether a survival period of 5days following spatial learning at either 1–5, 6–10 or 11–15days following BrdU administration would alter cell survival and/or activation of new neurons. Our results indicate that 5days after training in the Morris water task cell survival is unaltered by training on days 1–5, increased by training at days 6–10 and decreased when training occurs on days 11–15. Furthermore spatial learners trained on days 6–10 or 11–15 show greater activation of new neurons compared to cue-trained rats during a probe trial 5days after training. In addition, rats trained on the spatial task on days 11–15 had a greater number of activated new neurons compared to rats trained on the spatial task on days 6–10. These results suggest there is a gradual removal of older BrdU-labeled new neurons following spatial learning perhaps due to a competitive interaction with a population of younger BrdU-labeled new neurons.