Phosphorylation of CheY promotes association with the flagellar motor and ultimately controls the directional bias of the motor. However, biochemical studies of activated CheY‐phosphate have been challenging due to the rapid hydrolysis of the aspartyl‐phosphate in vitro. An inert analog of Tm CheY‐phosphate, phosphono‐CheY, was synthesized by chemical modification and purified by cation‐exchange chromatography. Changes in HPLC retention times, chemical assays for phosphate and free thiol, and mass spectrometry experiments demonstrate modification of Cys54 with a phosphonomethyl group. Additionally, a crystal structure showed electron density for the phosphonomethyl group at Cys54, consistent with a modification at that position. Subsequent biochemical experiments confirmed that protein crystals were phosphono‐CheY. Isothermal titration calorimetry and fluorescence polarization binding assays demonstrated that phosphono‐CheY bound a peptide derived from FliM, a native partner of CheY‐phosphate, with a dissociation constant of ∼29 µM, at least sixfold more tightly than unmodified CheY. Taken together these results suggest that Tm phosphono‐CheY is a useful and unique analog of Tm CheY‐phosphate.