This paper presents a mesh objective method for modeling crack propagation in brittle materials using a conventional finite element formulation. The primary shortcoming of the smeared crack approach is its pathological sensitivity to the mesh orientation, which is manifested by shear locking and stress field misalignment around the crack tip. Such undesirable characteristics preclude the ability to model arbitrary crack propagation at an angle through the mesh. Several techniques are developed to address these shortcomings. First, to preclude shear locking, a modified failure constitutive model is developed, which projects out the spurious stress increments as the crack opens. If a crack exists in an element, a crack tracking algorithm is used to identify the neighboring elements most likely to show crack continuation. This algorithm also identifies a crossover element when a crack passes through adjacent sides of an element. Then, the characteristic element length used in the constitutive equation is changed with the objective of providing the correct failure energy per unit crack length, a procedure called crossover scaling. The examples provided demonstrate that the developed methods work collectively to provide a simple and efficient method for modeling failure in brittle materials without mesh bias.