We investigate the electrorheological (ER) properties of clay (montmorillonite, sepiolite, and laponite®). The selected clays allow to distinguish between planar particles of different sizes (montmorillonite and laponite®), and elongated ones (sepiolite). The effect of coating them with the surfactant CTAB improves dispersibility in the oil medium and favors the ER response, prticularly in the case of laponite®, whereas in the case of montmorillonite, microscopic observations show that the columnar structures are broken in places leading to a reduced yield stress. Both the static yield stress and the storage modulus grow faster with the field in sepiolite suspensions as compared to laponite®. When dealing with mixed systems, it is found that the field-induced montmorillonite structures are reinforced by the addition of either laponite® or sepiolite, whereas when the latter two are combined, it is laponite® that dominates the ER response.