Metrologically traceable reference values add an essential benefit to interlaboratory comparisons: unlike consensus values, they can be used to establish national and international comparability. Furthermore, the participating laboratories obtain a reliable and unbiased benchmark to check their results for accuracy. Usually, metrologically traceable reference values are obtained by so-called primary methods which demand excessive efforts at great expense. Within the framework of two national drinking-water interlaboratory comparisons (proficiency testing rounds), a new approach to provide metrologically traceable reference values was applied. It is solely based on existing data which were collected during the comparison itself. Lead (Pb) measurements serve as an example to show how metrologically traceable reference values were derived from the lead amount added during sample preparation and the amount of lead already present in the drinking-water matrix used to prepare these samples. Within this approach, the matrix content is calculated in a way similar to a standard addition experiment. An uncertainty budget for the reference value was set up which describes the link to the corresponding SI units. Isotope dilution mass spectrometry (IDMS) as a primary method was used to validate this approach in the case of cadmium, chromium, copper, lead, and nickel.