The objective of this study was to manufacture a shortening using chemical interesterification (IT) of tallow-sunflower oil blends to replace fish oil in the present formulation, which is now in short supply in Chile. The significant variables of the IT process were obtained by 24−1 fractional factorial design. The proportion of tallow (T) in the blend, catalyst concentration, and reaction temperature had a significant effect on the melting point (mp) (P≤0.05). IT of tallow and sunflower oil blends (90∶10 and 70∶30) diminished the mp, dropping point, and refractive index compared to tallow. However, a noninteresterified 90∶10 blend mp was not significantly different from tallow. IT produced a solid fat content (SFC) profile of IT90∶10 blend that was appropriate for use in shortenings for the baking industry. Blending and IT of the 90∶10 blend increased the melting profile of the tallow and the melting range from −40 to 60°C while the endotherms of the middle-melting triacylglycerols (TAG) decreased. The IT90∶10 blend hardnesswas 70% lower than tallow hardness, and the crystal network was composed of large spherulites in a network. IT resulted in an appropriate method to improve physical properties of tallow, whereas blending did not significantly modify it. The interesterification changed the SFC profile of IT90∶10, giving a more appropriate shortening for use in the baking industry.