Under field conditions, females of the chestnut weevil Curculio elephas select their oviposition sites. In sleeve experiments, when the number of fruits is limited, females avoid 17% of available chestnuts and concentrate their eggs in the others. In the field, on average, 56.3 and 27.8% of the infested fruits contain one or two immatures (eggs and larvae). The oviposition site selection is neither influenced by host size nor by the presence of immature conspecifics. Choice experiments in the laboratory suggest that female weevils do not deposit repellent chemical markers on the fruits. Moreover, sleeve experiments indicate that selection is not influenced by the noise made by larvae while feeding inside a fruit. In general, the most probable hypothesis is that Curculio elephas exploits only hosts of highest feeding quality.