Behavior selection is the key procedure in cooperation activity, which regularly determines the final direction of the group. This paper focuses on several concrete evolutionary game models, aiming at investigating the selection of individual behavior in the process of evolution. Related simulations have proved that in regard to different games, payoff matrix was closely connected to the final behavior selection for individuals. Besides, a special method of punishment reward mechanism is introduced in public goods game to settle tragedy of the commons. Simulations demonstrate the feasibility and efficiency of this approach in solving such tragedies. Our work may be significant in developing creative solutions to the problem of strategy selection of individuals in an activity.