This paper presents the application of a Fuzzy Decision Support System (FDSS) model designed to assist managers in their decision process related with the choice of the best alternative to face Supply Chain (SC) disturbances. The FDSS operates supported on two main pillars, one is the use of Fuzzy Set Theory to model the uncertainty associated with disturbance occurrences, their effects on the SC and the computation of a Performance Index; the other is the use of ARENA (commercial simulation tool) to study the behavior of a SC subject to disturbances, and the effects of the implementation of mitigation or contingency plans designed to counter such disturbances. Using this FDSS, the decision maker can choose which the best solution is for his company considering not only his company's characteristics, but also the characteristics of the other SC entities.