Mixed-mode stable tearing crack growth events in Arcan plate specimens made of aluminum alloy 2024-T3 are simulated using three-dimensional (3D) finite element methods. A modeling/simulation procedure utilizing a mixed-mode CTOD fracture criterion and the custom 3D crack growth simulation software, CRACK3D, with an automatic local re-meshing option is demonstrated. Simulation predictions of the load–crack extension curve and the in-plane curvilinear crack growth path are compared with experimental measurements for various mixed-mode loading cases. Issues such as the effects of near-tip finite element size and crack extension increment size on simulation predictions are investigated.