This study explores the influence of source photon energy on eye plaque brachytherapy dose distributions for a 16mm COMS plaque filled with 103 Pd, 125 I, or 131 Cs sources or monoenergetic photon emissions ranging from 12keV to 100keV. Dose distributions were similarly created for all permutations of three common brachytherapy seed designs. Within this range, sources with average energy ≤22keV may reduce dose to the opposite eye wall by more than a factor of 2 while maintaining tolerable proximal sclera doses when prescribing to depths of 9mm or less. Current commercially-available brachytherapy sources can exhibit up to 15% relative dosimetric sensitivity to seed design at regions within the eye.