Building on calls to examine intra-individual variability in personality, we examined such variability in narrative. In Study 1, participants (n=553) provided three narratives (either self-defining, turning point, transgression, low point, or trauma memories; n=1659 narratives). Narratives were coded for coherence, autobiographical reasoning, resolution, and emotional expression. Variability was highest for resolution, lowest for coherence, and was related to well-being, depending on narrative feature and event type. In Study 2, participants (n=103) engaged in a ‘narrative recognition’ task to see if they could identify which narratives came from the same individual. Recognizability was substantial, but not related to variability or well-being. Results showcase the importance of addressing intra-individual variability by narrative feature and event type.