The effect of recycled HDPE on plane-strain fracture properties of pristine HDPE was studied using the essential work of fracture concept. The plane-strain specific EWF decreased linearly as recycled content increased while the plane-strain specific non-EWF exponentially decreased. The specific non-EWF was investigated using the extended finite element method. The nonlinearity of specific non-EWF was influenced by the shape factor (βD) and the specific non-essential fracture work per unit volume (wp,D), both of which were non-linearly related to recycled content. Blending brittle recycled material to ductile pristine HDPE decreased the fracture toughness and the crack growth resistance.