DFT-calculated structures based on 1H NMR chemical shifts in solution vs. structures solved by single-crystal X-ray and crystalline-sponge methods: Assessing specific sources of discrepancies

DFT calculations of ¹H NMR chemical shifts, using various functionals and basis sets, the conductor-like polarizable continuum model and discrete solute-solvent hydrogen bond interactions have been used to derive the solution structures of methyl salicylate and methyl 2,5-dihydroxybenzoate. We demonstrate that very good agreement between experimental and computed ¹H NMR chemical shifts can be obtained for various basis sets. The DFT structures in solution were compared with the recently reported X-ray structure, solved by the crystalline-sponge method, of the methyl salicylate and the single-crystal X-ray structure of methyl 2,5-dihydroxybenzoate. It is demonstrated that the information provided by ¹H NMR chemical shifts about the solution structure is significantly more precise than that obtained by the single-crystal X-ray and the crystalline-sponge methods.