A 71-year-old man with class IV congestive heart failure and an infected pacemaker/implantable cardioverter defibrillator (ICD) underwent median sternotomy for removal of endocardial leads with a 15-mm vegetation. Cardiac output during biventricular pacing was optimized with an aortic flow probe, a multi-electrode left ventricular patch, and a randomized protocol assessing 54 combinations of pacing site and right ventricle–left ventricle delay. Results that were assessed with response surface methodology determined permanent epicardial lead position and timing. The difference between the best and worst site-timing combinations altered cardiac index by nearly 70%. This experience demonstrates potential importance of the epicardial approach to site-timing optimization for biventricular pacing.