Type 2 diabetes mellitus (DM) and Alzheimer’s disease (AD) share epidemiological and biochemical features. Both are characterized by insoluble protein aggregates with a fibrillar conformation – amylin in Type 2 DM pancreatic islets, and Aβ in AD brain. To determine whether amylin shares neurotoxic properties with Aβ, we incubated hippocampal and cortical neurons with Aβ42 and human amylin. Different from non-amyloidogenic rat amylin, both caused a dose-, time- and cell type-specific neurotoxicity supporting the notion of a similar toxic mechanism. Depending on the cell type, this finding is also supported by co-incubation of human amylin and Aβ.