The Ψ[CH2NH] reduced amide bond is a peptide isostere widely used in the development of bioactive pseudopeptides. Reported here is a method of chemoenzymatic posttranslational modification for the synthesis of Ψ[CH2NH]‐containing peptides converted from ribosomally expressed peptides. The posttranslational conversion composed of an enzymatic cyclodehydration and facile two‐step chemical reduction achieves deoxygenation of a specific amide bond present in a nonprotected peptide in water. This method generates the Ψ[CH2NH] bond in peptides and is applicable to various peptide sequences, potentially enabling the preparation of a library of Ψ[CH2NH]‐containing peptides.