Abstract. It is well-known (due to C. Parsons) that the extension of primitive recursive arithmetic PRA by first-order predicate logic and the rule of -induction -IR is -conservative over PRA. We show that this is no longer true in the presence of function quantifiers and quantifier-free choice for numbers AC -qf. More precisely we show that PRA -IR AC -qf proves the totality of the Ackermann function, where PRA is the extension of PRA by number and function quantifiers and -IR may contain function parameters. This is true even for PRA -IR -IR AC -qf, where -IR is the restriction of -IR without function parameters.